Our reviews
Reviews from Grubhub
lauren
Top Reviewer
i adore this place. addicted to their regularass salad and they always accommodate my request for no nasty feta. pizzas on point, i really miss their buffalo sandwich they used to have, delivery is relatively speedy and delivery person is always kind.
Becca
3 reviews
Foood was amazing. Got the chicken parm with vodka sauce and a cannoli. Everything was fresh and delicious! Would definitely recommend.
William
4 reviews
The pizza was DON CORLEONE approved and good
It made my taste buds an offer I couldnt refuse
It made my taste buds an offer I couldnt refuse
Dreni
1 review
Great pizza made with freshest ingredients. By far the best pizza in East Village.
Yuliya
1 review
Order was ready promptly, pizza was great, would order again!
Reviews from Seamless.com
Shelby
Top Reviewer
Ordered the chicken bacon & ranch pizza and added spinach, would definitely recommend! The chicken is kinda breaded, crispy like potatoes almost. The spinach is like steamed and in little piles on the pizza, not like laid flat and hard to bite into. Would definitely recommend and will be ordering from here again!
Cynthia
Top Reviewer
Honestly, I think Proto's is one of the most under-rated Italian places in the city. I've never had their pizza, but the plates and heros are some of the best I've had in a long time - and at a fair and affordable price for the quality. Love it here, I order often and it's consistently great. I highly recommend!
Chloe
Top Reviewer
Delivery was early, and the order was correct except our pizza didn't have pepperoni as I ordered. I called proto's and the man who answered was so sweet and apologetic. I truly appreciate his apology and how quickly the food came. Will be ordering again. The food is delicious!
NEIL
Top Reviewer
Best pizza I have had downtown. Recently moved from the UES and have tried several pizza places in and around the village, including Lombardi's. I would definitely rate this as the best so far. Delivery was 10 mins over the the delivery window but well worth it.
Alexis
2 reviews
I researched for 40 minutes on Seamless for a great Italian restaurant, and I'm happy I found Proto! The prices were hard to beat, and the food was really delicious. The portions were better than I expected given the prices. I will order again.